Searching for The Best Medicare Supplement Plans Available In St. Augustine, Florida?
Tailored Medigap Plan quotes for St. Johns County seniors. Get personalized coverage today.
Why Medicare Supplements Matter Here in St. Augustine: Your Guide to Coverage
Finding the Right Medigap Coverage for Your St. Augustine Retirement
Choosing a Medicare Supplement plan doesn’t have to be complicated. Whether you’re already enjoying retirement in St. Augustine or turning 65 soon, we help residents across St. Johns County find Medigap coverage that fits their health needs and budget. From covering those gaps in Original Medicare to protecting you from unexpected medical bills, the right plan makes all the difference in your peace of mind. Click Here To Compare All Plans
St. Augustine Senior Demographics & Lifestyle
According to U.S. Census data, St. Augustine has a historic tourism-based city:
- Population: Approximately 15,000
- Residents 65+: About 22%
- Median age: 42 years
- Median household income: $58,000
- Home ownership rate: 52%
- Affordability: Moderate; tourism-influenced pricing
Many St. Augustine retirees enjoy:
- Moderate Senior Population: 22% seniors in tourism-focused city
- Historic Character: America’s oldest continuously occupied European settlement
- Tourism Hub: Vibrant downtown with shops, restaurants, attractions
- Flagler Hospital: Hospital LOCAL in city
- Cultural Amenities: Museums, historic sites, performing arts
- Walkable Downtown: Pedestrian-friendly historic district
- Moderate Homeownership: 52% own homes, mixed rental market
- Strategic Location: 40 minutes to Jacksonville, beach access nearby
- Diverse Economy: Tourism, healthcare, education, historic preservation
- Matanzas Bay Waterfront: Beautiful bayfront location
- Year-Round Events: Festivals, historic celebrations, cultural activities
- Unique Character: Living history combined with modern amenities
St. Augustine attracts culturally-engaged middle-class retirees seeking historic character with tourism amenities. The combination of moderate costs, historic significance as America’s oldest city, Flagler Hospital locally, walkable downtown, cultural attractions, and unique living history atmosphere makes it ideal for retirees who prioritize cultural engagement, historic character, walkable urban living, and distinctive community with year-round activities.
What's the process?
We’re easy to reach. Most use our form. This allows us to call you at the time of your convenience. We’ll ask about your Part B date, current coverage (if any), budget guardrails.
- Clear, Unbiased, Fast
- Licensed since 1994
- FL License #A169316
We shop carriers and identify underwriting flags (if any), Once we’ve identified several, we’ll contact you to set up the best time to go over our findings.
- No pushy sales theater
- Right-sized plan
- Application concierge
Right-sized Medigap plan (G, N, or fit) for your ZIP and budget
Application concierge (e-app done right, the first time)
Annual rate-check so you don’t overpay next renewal
- Same day quotes
- Apples-to-apples
- 24-hour response
What Is a Medicare Supplement Plan?
Medicare Supplement plans — often called Medigap — are optional policies you can buy from private insurance companies to help pay the costs that Original Medicare (Part A and Part B) doesn’t fully cover. Think of them as “gap fillers.”
With Medicare alone, you’re still on the hook for things like deductibles, coinsurance, and copays. A Medigap plan can step in and cover some or all of those out-of-pocket costs.
How Do They Work?
You stay enrolled in Original Medicare.
Medicare pays its share of approved healthcare costs.
Your Medigap plan pays its share after that.
You still use your red, white, and blue Medicare card at the doctor’s office — nothing changes there. The Supplement is just a backup, so you’re not left with big bills.
Fast Facts (Save Yourself Headaches)
- Medigap ≠ Advantage. Medigap works with Original Medicare; no networks, no referrals.
- Price is by ZIP/age/tobacco/household. Same benefits → different carrier rates.
- Timing matters. Your Part B date and Guaranteed Issue windows change underwriting.
- Doctor freedom. Any provider accepting Medicare. Traveling? You’re still covered.
Medigap vs. Advantage
- Medigap (We place it): higher premium, lower unpredictable costs, nationwide access, no network drama.
- Advantage (We don’t market it): lower premium, networks, authorizations, plan rules.
You want clarity, predictability, and freedom → Medigap usually wins.
What Drives Your Rate?
- ZIP code • Age (and birthday timing) • Tobacco status • Household discount • Carrier rate history
Why Florida Seniors Choose Medicare Supplements Only?
Nearly 30 Years of Experience
Chuck Lunsford has helped Florida residents navigate Medicare Supplement decisions since 1994. Licensed FL agent #A169316 with deep expertise across every Florida community—from Miami to the Panhandle.
Comprehensive Florida Coverage
We serve seniors in 50+ Florida communities with deep understanding of local healthcare landscapes and hospital access. Whether you’re in a bustling city or quiet rural town, we know your area’s unique challenges.
No-Pressure, Independent Guidance
We compare plans from multiple top-rated carriers to find the best value for YOUR situation—never locked into one company. Our educational approach means you make informed decisions at your own pace, with ongoing support after enrollment.
Which Plans Can You Choose in St. Augustine?
Plans are standardized by letter — A through N — so a Plan G in Florida has the same benefits as a Plan G in any other state. The big differences are in monthly premium, underwriting rules, and which carriers sell it in your area.
The most popular in Florida today are Plan G (covers nearly everything except the Part B deductible) and Plan N (lower premium, but you pay a copay for office and ER visits). Click Here To Compare All Plans
What to Bring to the Call
Medicare ID (red/white/blue card) • Part B start month/year • Med list (optional) • Must-have doctors/hospitals • Current coverage (if any)
What You Get
- Right-sized Medigap plan (G, N, or fit) for your city and your budget
- Same-day quotes
- Application concierge (clean e-app, first time)
- Annual rate-check so you don’t overpay
St. Augustine-Specific Notes
-
Community vs. Attained Age Rating: In Florida, most carriers use attained-age pricing — meaning your premium is based on the age you are when you enroll and can rise as you get older. That’s important to budget for.
-
Open Enrollment Window: You have a six-month guaranteed-issue period when you first enroll in Medicare Part B at age 65. After that, you may have to answer health questions to switch plans.
-
Household Discounts: Some Florida carriers offer a household or spousal discount if two people in the same household enroll.
-
Local Support: Since carriers and rates vary by county, we run quotes for your ZIP code to make sure you’re not overpaying.
What’s The Next Step?
If you’re turning 65 soon or already on Medicare and looking at options, we’ll compare every Medigap carrier available in your Florida county. You’ll see the actual premiums side by side, and we’ll walk you through how Plan G and Plan N stack up for your situation.
Why St. Augustine Residents Need Medicare Supplement Coverage
St. Augustine residents face healthcare challenges that make Medicare Supplement coverage important:
Local Hospital Access: St. Augustine has Flagler Hospital, a hospital located in the city providing emergency care, surgical services, and comprehensive hospital services. This is an important advantage for the historic city. For more complex care, Jacksonville hospitals (40 minutes) provide major medical center options.
Moderate Income with Tourism-Influenced Costs: With a median household income of $58,000, most St. Augustine residents balance moderate incomes with tourism-influenced higher living costs. The 22% senior population, while lower than pure retirement communities, still creates substantial healthcare demand. One hospitalization could cost $5,000-$15,000 without Medigap, a significant burden when managing tourism-area cost of living. For those who’ve chosen St. Augustine for historic character and cultural amenities, protecting assets is important.
Hurricane Matthew, Irma, and Storm History: As a coastal historic city, St. Augustine experienced significant hurricane impacts:
Hurricane Matthew (October 2016): Category 3 storm brought severe impacts:
- Significant storm surge flooding historic downtown and Matanzas Bay waterfront
- Historic district severely flooded with damage to historic structures
- Widespread power outages throughout city
- Extensive property damage requiring repairs
- Historic preservation challenges following flood damage
- Extended recovery for tourism-dependent economy
Hurricane Irma (September 2017): Category 1-2 impacts brought additional flooding, wind damage, power outages, and cumulative stress on historic structures and tourism economy.
Numerous tropical systems over centuries have repeatedly flooded the low-lying historic city, demonstrating ongoing coastal vulnerability.
The repeated hurricane flooding created stress for residents balancing moderate incomes with tourism-area costs, property damage requiring repairs, insurance challenges with premium increases in flood-prone historic areas, and demonstrated that low-lying historic St. Augustine faces significant coastal flooding vulnerability. The tourism economy disruptions from storms add economic stress. This context makes comprehensive insurance coverage, including Medigap, important for protecting assets.
Plan N: Practical Value for St. Augustine: For St. Augustine’s moderate income profile balanced against tourism-area costs, Plan N typically offers excellent value, saving $35-50 monthly versus Plan G. That’s $420-600 annually, meaningful savings when managing a higher cost of living. Plan N provides comprehensive protection with small copays ($20 office, $50 ER waived if admitted), making it practical for middle-class retirees in this historic tourism city.
About Lynn Haven: Community Snapshot for Seniors
Lynn Haven is a city of approximately 21,000 residents in Bay County in the Florida Panhandle. Located immediately northeast of Panama City along North Bay, Lynn Haven offers quality middle-class suburban living with reasonable Panama City access and remarkable post-Hurricane Michael recovery resilience.
According to U.S. Census data, about 20% of Lynn Haven residents are 65 or older (moderate senior percentage), with a median household income of $58,000 and a homeownership rate of 71% (very high). The demographic reflects middle-class retirees on moderate to good fixed incomes, working families, professionals, and people seeking quality Panhandle suburban living near Panama City. The economy centers on retail, services, professional employment, and proximity to Panama City jobs, creating a stable middle-class economy with family character.
St. Augustine’s defining characteristic is historic urban retirement living in America’s oldest city with 22% seniors, Flagler Hospital locally, walkable pedestrian-friendly historic downtown with shops and restaurants, living history atmosphere with preserved Spanish colonial architecture and cobblestone streets, tourism amenities providing year-round cultural activities and dining, Matanzas Bay waterfront location, moderate homeownership (52%) reflecting tourism-influenced rental market, and unique character combining centuries of history with modern coastal Florida living. The moderate senior population creates retiree presence within diverse tourism-focused communities.
The cost of living is moderate, influenced by the tourism economy. Home prices range from $250,000-$450,000 for standard in-town homes, with historic district properties $400,000-$800,000+. The 52% homeownership rate reflects the tourism-influenced rental market with substantial vacation rental and seasonal housing. For middle-class retirees, St. Augustine provides historic urban living with cultural amenities at moderate cost, though tourism influence raises prices above typical Florida cities.
The moderate senior population (22%) creates a retiree presence within the tourism-focused community. With about one-fifth of residents 65 or older, St. Augustine has adequate senior services while maintaining diverse age demographics from tourism and education sectors.
The moderate median household income ($58,000) reflects a mixed economy balancing tourism wages, healthcare, education, and retiree incomes, with cost of living higher than income alone suggests due to tourism influence.
The moderate homeownership rate (52%) reflects the tourism-influenced housing market with substantial rental properties, vacation rentals, and seasonal housing alongside permanent residents.
The county seat benefits (St. Johns County) provide government services, though Flagler Hospital and medical facilities serve as major healthcare anchors.
The Flagler Hospital LOCAL creates important healthcare advantage:
Flagler Hospital (LOCAL, in city) provides emergency care, surgical services, comprehensive hospital services, cardiac care, stroke center, handling most needs locally for residents.
Additionally:
- Baptist Medical Center Jacksonville (Jacksonville, 40 minutes north), major regional medical center
- UF Health Jacksonville (Jacksonville, 40 minutes north), academic medical center
Having a hospital locally plus major Jacksonville medical centers nearby provides solid healthcare access for the historic city.
The historic character creates THE distinguishing attraction. St. Augustine features America’s oldest continuously occupied European settlement (founded 1565), preserved Spanish colonial architecture, Castillo de San Marcos National Monument (17th century Spanish fort), historic downtown with cobblestone streets, centuries-old buildings housing shops and restaurants, living history atmosphere throughout city, and unique character as living museum with modern amenities.
The walkable downtown provides urban retirement appeal, with pedestrian-friendly historic district, shops and restaurants within walking distance, cultural attractions accessible on foot, bayfront parks and plazas, and urban lifestyle rare in Florida retirement destinations.
The tourism amenities enhance daily living, with excellent dining options throughout the historic district, year-round festivals and events, cultural activities and performances, museums and historic sites, art galleries, and vibrant community life from tourism infrastructure.
The cultural attractions provide engagement opportunities, including Lightner Museum, Colonial Quarter living history museum, Flagler College (former Ponce de León Hotel), Fountain of Youth Archaeological Park, historic churches, performing arts venues, and extensive cultural programming.
The Matanzas Bay waterfront creates scenic beauty, with a bayfront location providing water views, waterfront parks, marina access, and coastal character within a historic setting.
The convenient positioning provides regional access. St. Augustine’s location provides reasonable Jacksonville access (40 minutes) for major city amenities and medical centers, St. Augustine Beach (5-10 minutes) for Atlantic Ocean beaches, and Interstate 95 corridor access while maintaining distinctive historic character.
The hurricane Matthew, Irma, and flooding history demonstrates coastal vulnerability:
Hurricane Matthew (2016): Category 3 storm brought severe impacts with significant storm surge flooding inundating historic downtown and Matanzas Bay waterfront areas, historic district severely flooded damaging centuries-old structures and buildings, widespread power outages, extensive property damage requiring careful historic preservation repairs, tourism economy disruption, and extended recovery challenges.
Hurricane Irma (2017): Storm brought additional flooding, wind damage, power outages, and cumulative stress on historic structures barely recovered from Matthew.
Chronic Flooding: Low-lying historic city experiences regular tidal flooding, king tide flooding, and tropical system flooding demonstrating ongoing vulnerability.
Impact on Residents Balancing Moderate Incomes with Tourism-Area Costs: Property damage requiring repairs while managing higher cost of living, flood insurance extremely expensive in low-lying historic areas, wind insurance substantial for coastal location, tourism economy disruptions affecting employment and local economy, insurance premium increases straining budgets, and ongoing flood vulnerability creating persistent concern and expense.
The historic tourism character attracts culturally-engaged retirees seeking distinctive living history atmosphere, walkable urban lifestyle, cultural amenities, year-round activities, and unique character as America’s oldest city despite coastal flooding vulnerability.
The St. Johns County location provides historic Northeast Florida character with reasonable Jacksonville access and beach proximity.
Healthcare access reflects St. Augustine’s local advantage. Flagler Hospital (LOCAL) handles most needs, with major Jacksonville medical centers (40 minutes) available for complex care.
Retirees are drawn to St. Augustine for historic urban retirement in America’s oldest city, 22% senior population within diverse tourism-focused community, Flagler Hospital locally, walkable pedestrian-friendly historic downtown with shops and restaurants, living history atmosphere with preserved colonial architecture, tourism amenities providing excellent dining and cultural activities, Matanzas Bay waterfront location, cultural attractions including museums and historic sites, year-round festivals and events, unique character combining centuries of history with modern coastal living, and distinctive retirement experience unavailable elsewhere in Florida.
For culturally-engaged middle-class retirees seeking historic urban retirement with walkable downtown, cultural amenities, living history atmosphere, tourism infrastructure providing dining and activities, and unique character as America’s oldest city despite moderate costs and coastal flooding vulnerability, St. Augustine provides exceptional historic urban retirement experience.
Healthcare Access in St. Augustine, Florida
St. Augustine residents benefit from local hospital access:
Local Hospital:
- Flagler Hospital, 400 Health Park Boulevard, St. Augustine (LOCAL), providing emergency care, surgical services, comprehensive hospital services, cardiac care, stroke center
Nearby Major Medical Centers:
- Baptist Medical Center South
Found at 14550 Old St. Augustine Rd, Jacksonville, FL 32258 (just over the county line in Duval County), this facility is approximately 25 miles from central St. Augustine, a 30-minute drive. It provides comprehensive care and accepts Medicare Assignment. - UF Health St. Johns
Located at 400 Health Park Blvd, St. Augustine, FL 32086 (co-located with Flagler Hospital), this facility is about 3 miles from central St. Augustine, a 7-minute drive. It offers specialty care and accepts Medicare Assignment. - Mayo Clinic Primary Care – St. Augustine
Found at 110 Southwood Lake Dr, St. Augustine, FL 32086, this center is roughly 5 miles from central St. Augustine, a 10-minute drive. It focuses on primary and preventive care, and accepts Medicare Assignment. - Ascension St. Vincent’s St. Johns County
Located at 2001 County Rd 210, St. Johns, FL 32259, this hospital is about 15 miles from central St. Augustine, a 20-minute drive. It provides emergency and specialty care, and accepts Medicare Assignment. - Baptist Health Emergency Center – World Golf Village
Found at 205 Trinity Way, St. Augustine, FL 32092, this freestanding ER is approximately 10 miles from central St. Augustine, a 15-minute drive. It offers urgent care and accepts Medicare Assignment.
Solid Healthcare Access:
St. Augustine residents benefit from solid healthcare access with Flagler Hospital locally handling most needs, important for the 22% senior population. Major Jacksonville medical centers (40 minutes) provide comprehensive tertiary care options.
Having comprehensive Medicare Supplement coverage is important for St. Augustine residents because even with local hospital, one hospitalization could cost $5,000-$15,000+ without Medigap. Balancing moderate income with tourism-influenced higher cost of living makes protecting assets important.
Pharmacies:
- Multiple CVS Pharmacy, Walgreens, Publix Pharmacy locations throughout St. Augustine
Medicare-Accepting Doctors Serving St. Augustine Residents
Primary Care: Multiple primary care physicians throughout St. Augustine serving residents, plus Flagler Hospital physician practices and St. Johns County Health Department preventive services.
Specialists: Specialists in St. Augustine and nearby Jacksonville providing comprehensive options.
Hospital Services: Flagler Hospital (LOCAL) for most needs, with major Jacksonville medical centers for complex care.
Always verify Medicare acceptance.
Driving Distances to Key Facilities
|
Facility |
Location |
Distance |
Drive Time |
|
Flagler Hospital |
St. Augustine |
Local |
5-10 minutes |
|
St. Augustine Beach |
St. Augustine Beach |
5 miles |
10 minutes |
|
Downtown Historic District |
St. Augustine |
Local |
Walking distance |
|
Jacksonville hospitals |
Jacksonville |
35 miles |
40 minutes |
I use Medicare.gov’s Care Compare and Florida Health Finder to locate Medicare-accepting doctors and hospitals, ensuring affordable care with United American plans.
We Offer Expert Guidance to Your Perfect Supplement Plan
We’ll dive into your unique needs, simplify the maze of plan options, and guide you with clear, honest advice. My hands-on approach, backed by thousands of client success stories—ensures you get coverage that fits your life, stress-free.
We analyze your healthcare needs, budget, and preferences to recommend the best Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans, clarifying coverage gaps like deductibles or copays that Original Medicare doesn’t cover
We simplify the complex enrollment process, ensuring clients meet deadlines, understand eligibility, and avoid penalties, while navigating them through plan options with clear, jargon-free explanations.
We offer continued assistance post-enrollment, helping with claims, plan changes, or unexpected issues, and stay updated on policy shifts to keep clients’ coverage aligned with their evolving needs.
Our Services for St. Augustine, FL Residents
We specialize in helping St. Johns County historic city residents:
✓ Free Plan Comparisons (ZIP 32080, 32084, 32086, 32092, 32095) ✓ Value Focus for middle-class retirees balancing tourism-area costs ✓ No-Pressure Guidance ✓ Year-Round Support ✓ Understanding of historic tourism community and cultural character ✓ Recognition of coastal flooding vulnerability
Common Medicare Questions from St. Augustine Residents
“Do I need a Medigap plan if Flagler Hospital is right here?” Yes, important protection. Even with local hospital, one hospitalization costs $5,000-$15,000+ without Medigap. Balancing moderate income with tourism-influenced higher cost of living makes comprehensive coverage important for protecting assets.
“Which plan provides good value in a tourism area?” Plan N typically offers excellent value for St. Augustine residents, saving $420-600 annually versus Plan G. With tourism-influenced cost of living, Plan N provides comprehensive protection while managing overall budget effectively.
“Can I use my Medigap plan at Jacksonville hospitals?” Absolutely! Medicare Supplement plans work with any doctor or hospital accepting Original Medicare, Flagler Hospital locally, Jacksonville medical centers, or anywhere you travel.
“When should I enroll?” During your Medigap Open Enrollment Period (6 months starting when you’re 65+ and enrolled in Part B).
Get Your Free St. Augustine Medicare Supplement Quote Today
Other Cities and Towns In St. Johns County
World Golf Village, Palm Valley, St. Augustine Beach, Fruit Cove, Ponte Vedra Beach, St. Augustine Shores, St. Augustine South, Sawgrass, Vilano Beach, Hastings, Gonzalez, Pensacola Station, Goulding, Century, Molino
Find Your Plan Today
Don’t miss your chance for the right Medicare Supplement plan. Call us at 1-239-633-4392, email info@medicaresupplementsonly.com, or fill out our form for a free consultation. Let’s make Medicare work for you. Learn more at the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
Disclaimer:
MedicareSupplementsOnly.com is owned and operated by Charles “Chuck” Lunsford, a Life & Health insurance agent licensed in Florida (License A169316, active since 1994). Insurance product descriptions are for informational/marketing purposes only. The policy and any riders issued by the insurer contain the full terms, conditions, exclusions, and limitations. Eligibility, rates, and benefits are determined by the issuing carrier and are subject to underwriting and change.
We do not market Advantage plans. Not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. This is a solicitation of insurance. Availability varies by area. Services available where licensed.
We specialize in Medicare Supplement (Medigap) insurance and related products. We do not offer Medicare Advantage (MA) plans.
MedicareSupplementOnly.com is not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. This is a solicitation of insurance; a licensed agent may contact you. Products and services are available only where licensed. Availability and carrier participation vary by state and by product.
No tax or legal advice is provided. Consult your tax advisor or attorney regarding your specific situation. Email and text communications may not be fully secure; please avoid sending sensitive personal information unless requested through a secure channel. All trademarks and logos are the property of their respective owners.